Saint Joan of Arc (Jeanne la Pucelle): Difference between revisions
Line 34: | Line 34: | ||
These pages present a Catholic view of Saint Joan of Arc that is consistent with the vetted historical record. It reviews the facts of the life and accomplishments of Saint Joan, as well as their historical context. It offers commentary and criticism of historical and academic views of her, especially as regards the secularization and ideological contortions of her life and legacy. | These pages present a Catholic view of Saint Joan of Arc that is consistent with the vetted historical record. It reviews the facts of the life and accomplishments of Saint Joan, as well as their historical context. It offers commentary and criticism of historical and academic views of her, especially as regards the secularization and ideological contortions of her life and legacy. | ||
The divine origin of Joan's visions (which I will call her "Voices") is assumed here,<ref>As opposed to skeptical treatments of Joan that merely assume that her visions were not divine; similarly, these pages will not automatically assume a divine nature for everything she did nor what she was said to have done: the approach here is faithful yet cautious.</ref> which enables important typological and scriptural connections to Joan's life and acts. As opposed to skeptical treatments of Joan that simply assume that her visions were not of divine origin, these pages will assume a divine nature for them, only with prudence. The approach here is faithful yet cautious. | The divine origin of Joan's visions (which I will call her "Voices") is assumed here,<ref name=":12">As opposed to skeptical treatments of Joan that merely assume that her visions were not divine; similarly, these pages will not automatically assume a divine nature for everything she did nor what she was said to have done: the approach here is faithful yet cautious.</ref> which enables important typological and scriptural connections to Joan's life and acts. As opposed to skeptical treatments of Joan that simply assume that her visions were not of divine origin, these pages will assume a divine nature for them, only with prudence. The approach here is faithful yet cautious. | ||
This discussion of Saint Joan here is analysis not narrative. Although the narrative is presented, the approach here is thematic not strictly chronological. To review a straight chronology of her life, please see the [[Saint Joan of Arc (Jeanne la Pucelle)/Joan of Arc Timeline|Joan of Arc Timeline]] or find a good narrative treatment of her from the [[Saint Joan of Arc (Jeanne la Pucelle)/Joan of Arc bibliography|Joan of Arc bibliography]]. | This discussion of Saint Joan here is analysis not narrative. Although the narrative is presented, the approach here is thematic not strictly chronological. To review a straight chronology of her life, please see the [[Saint Joan of Arc (Jeanne la Pucelle)/Joan of Arc Timeline|Joan of Arc Timeline]] or find a good narrative treatment of her from the [[Saint Joan of Arc (Jeanne la Pucelle)/Joan of Arc bibliography|Joan of Arc bibliography]]. | ||
Line 71: | Line 71: | ||
Notes on archaic word use: | Notes on archaic word use: | ||
* "gentle knight" is translated from the French ''gentil'', which means not "delicate," but "honorable" or "noble"<ref>See for example, Joan saying, "Le <mark>gentil</mark> rojr ara au jour duj la plus grant a victoire quHleutpièça. Et m* a dit mon conseil qu* ils a sont tous nostres" ([https://archive.org/details/procsdecondamna02frangoog/page/99/mode/2up?q=gentil Quicherat Vol III, p. 99])</ref> | * "gentle knight" is translated from the French ''gentil'', which means not "delicate," but "honorable" or "noble"<ref name=":13">See for example, Joan saying, "Le <mark>gentil</mark> rojr ara au jour duj la plus grant a victoire quHleutpièça. Et m* a dit mon conseil qu* ils a sont tous nostres" ([https://archive.org/details/procsdecondamna02frangoog/page/99/mode/2up?q=gentil Quicherat Vol III, p. 99])</ref> | ||
* "fair Lord" is translated from the French ''juste'', which means "just" not "good looking"<ref>citation to add</ref></div></div> | * "fair Lord" is translated from the French ''juste'', which means "just" not "good looking"<ref>citation to add</ref></div></div> | ||
Line 1,018: | Line 1,018: | ||
Historians have recognized this aspect of Joan's influence upon events, especially in the re-militarization of France under de Richemont after he expelled La Trémoïlle from the French court. Arriving with his soldiers to Jargeau was his first ploy to regain power as Constable of France. By welcoming him, and forcing the general, d'Alençons, to accept his presence, it was Joan who put into place the dynamics that would lead to the reconciliation of Burgundy with France four years after her death. Yet long before the final defeat of the English, it was a key turning point, if not as important as Orléans and the crowning of Charles at Reims, the contingent events that allowed all the rest to happen. | Historians have recognized this aspect of Joan's influence upon events, especially in the re-militarization of France under de Richemont after he expelled La Trémoïlle from the French court. Arriving with his soldiers to Jargeau was his first ploy to regain power as Constable of France. By welcoming him, and forcing the general, d'Alençons, to accept his presence, it was Joan who put into place the dynamics that would lead to the reconciliation of Burgundy with France four years after her death. Yet long before the final defeat of the English, it was a key turning point, if not as important as Orléans and the crowning of Charles at Reims, the contingent events that allowed all the rest to happen. | ||
La Trémoïlle | La Trémoïlle and de Richemont's mutual history and animosities were large. Both were a piece of work. Both sided with the Armagnac cause, and both fought at Agincourt were captured there by the English. La Trémoïlle was released right away, while de Richemont, who was injured in the battle, was held for five years, after which he joined the English cause. He convinced his brother, the Duke of Brittany, to join the Burgundians in support of the English at the 1420 Treaty of Troyes. The English rewarded de Richemont, but with a title and not a command, so, frustrated at the sidelining, he returned to the French court, where he brought his brother back into the Armagnac fold in a treaty with Charles VII. At the French court, de Richemont worked with Trémoïlle to oust the top court minister, Pierre de Giac,<ref>See [https://www.britannica.com/biography/Georges-de-La-Tremoille?utm_source=chatgpt.com Georges de La Trémoille | Military Commander, Courtier, Diplomat | Britannica] which states that after kidnapping and drowning Giac, La Trémoïlle married the guy's widow.</ref> but things fell apart in 1427 when La Trémoïlle, having taken over from Giac, turned on de Richemont, in part because of his volatile personality, and part because de Richemont's brother had been forced into signing a truce with the English, which was seen as a betrayal by the French, and thus the the severe animosities between them. In 1433, de Richemont took revenge upon La Trémoïlle, and had him kidnapped and ransomed with the pledge to stay out of the French Court. But there's more: turns out that La Trémoïlle had previously spent a couple years serving the Burgundians before rejoining the Armagnacs and Dauphin Charles in 1413, and de Richemont was married to a daughter of John the Fearless. Amidst the oscillating alliances and defections stood John the Fearless, the Duke of Burgundy, who had an informal understanding of mutual support with de Richemont's brother, the Duke of Brittany. Burgundy knew these characters well, and so after Joan's death, the Duke offered de Richemont lands that belonged to La Trémoïlle , in exchange for his loyalty, | ||
>>here | >>here | ||
{| class="wikitable" | |||
|+ | |||
!Date | |||
!La Trémoïlle | |||
!de Richemont | |||
! | |||
|- | |||
|Early life | |||
|Grew up in the Burgundian court under John the Fearless, Duke of Burgundy | |||
|Younger son of the Duke of Brittany, John IV and Joanna of Navarre, who subsequently became Henry IV of England's Queen | |||
| | |||
|- | |||
|1410-1414 | |||
|seems to have switched loyalties to Armagnac faction in 1413<ref name=":13" /> | |||
|aligns with Armagnac faction during open conflict with Burgundians | |||
| | |||
|- | |||
|1415 | |||
|fights for French at Agincourt; captured and soon released | |||
|fights for French at Agincourt; wounded, captured and held for five years<ref name=":12" /> | |||
| | |||
|- | |||
|1420 | |||
| | |||
|convinces brother, Duke of Brittany to join English side in Treaty of Troyes that recognized the English king as heir to France | |||
| | |||
|- | |||
|1422 | |||
| | |||
|entitled by English as Duke of Touraine | |||
| | |||
|- | |||
|1424 | |||
| | |||
|returns to French Court and made Constable of France | |||
| | |||
|- | |||
|1425 | |||
| | |||
|brother, the Duke of Brittany sign Treaty of Saumur with Charles VII | |||
| | |||
|- | |||
|1427 | |||
|named Grand-Chamberlain of France by Charles VII | |||
|English raids force Duke of Brittany to enter truce, separating Brittany from France | |||
| | |||
|- | |||
| | |||
| | |||
|kicked out of French court by La Trémoïlle | |||
| | |||
|- | |||
|1429 | |||
| | |||
|in June brings army to join Joan of Arc, and fights with the French at Battle of Patay | |||
| | |||
|- | |||
|1432 | |||
| | |||
|March, Treaty of Rennes signed between Charles VII and Duke of Brittany, enhancing de Richemont's status with French court | |||
| | |||
|- | |||
| | |||
| | |||
| | |||
| | |||
|- | |||
|1433 | |||
|removed from French court by de Richemont | |||
|overthrows La Trémoïlle | |||
| | |||
|- | |||
|1435 | |||
| | |||
|helps negotiate Trety of Arras which re-aligns Burgundy to the French | |||
| | |||
|- | |||
|1444 | |||
| | |||
|heads reorganization of the French army on professional terms | |||
| | |||
|- | |||
|1450 | |||
| | |||
|Command French victory at Battle of Formigny, in Normandy, and lays seige on Caen | |||
| | |||
|} | |||